Mortgages and Credit Reports
Many home buyers are very worried about
how their credit report will affect their ability to buy
a home. We even heard one story that an applicant was
denied a mortgage because he had returned a rented
videotape late!
Of
course, that could never happen. Most people will not
need to worry about the effects of their credit history
during the mortgage process. However, you can be better
prepared if you get a copy of your credit report to
review before you apply for your mortgage. That way, if
there are any errors you can take steps to correct them
before you make your application.
If
you have had credit problems, be prepared to discuss
them honestly with a mortgage professional and come to
your application meeting with a written explanation.
Responsible mortgage professionals know there can be
legitimate reasons for credit problems, such as
unemployment, illness or other financial difficulties.
If you had a problem that's been corrected, and your
payments have been on time for a year or more, your
credit may be considered satisfactory.
ABC's of Mortgage Credit
The mortgage industry tends to create its
own language and credit rating is no exception. BC
Mortgage lending gets its name from the grading of one's
credit based on such things such as payment history,
amount of debt payments, bankruptcies, equity position,
credit scores, etc.
We
have compiled a guide to help you estimate your credit
grade. This is only a guide as many companies have
exceptions that may result in more strict or more
lenient guidelines.
-
A+
720-850
-
A
620-719
-
B
590-619
-
C
560-589
-
D
530-559
-
E
500-529
The
figures shown here are estimates. When trying to figure
your credit grade, keep in mind the following
principles:
-
Other
Things Being Equal-When your have derogatory credit,
all of the other aspects of the loan need to be in
order. Equity, stability, income, documentation,
assets, etc. play a larger role in the approval
decision.
-
Worst
Case Scenario-When determining your grade, various
combinations are allowed, but the worst case will push
your grade to a lower credit guide. Mortgage Lates and
Bankruptcies are the most important.
-
Going
Once, Going Twice-Credit patterns are very important.
A high number of recent inquiries and more than a few
outstanding loans may signal a problem. A "willingness
to pay" is important, thus late payments in the same
time period is better than random lates as they signal
an effort to pay even after falling behind.
Credit Guide Scoring
In a nutshell, credit scoring is a
statistical method of assessing the credit risk of a
loan applicant. The score is a number that rates the
likelihood an individual will pay back a loan. The score
looks at the following items: past delinquencies,
derogatory payment behavior, current debt level, length
of credit history, types of credit, number of inquiries.
Credit scoring will place borrowers in one of three
general categories.
First, a borrower with a score 680 and above may be
considered an A+ loan. The loan will involve basic
underwriting, probably through a "computerized automated
underwriting" system and be completed within minutes.
Borrowers falling into this category may have a good
chance to obtain a lower rate of interest and close
their loan within a couple of days.
Second, a score below 680 but above 620 may indicate
underwriters will take a closer look at the file in
determining potential risks. Borrowers falling into this
category may find the process and underwriting time no
different than in the past. Supplemental credit
documentation and letters of explanation may be required
before an underwriting decision is made. Loans within
this FICO scoring range may allow borrowers to obtain
"A" pricing, but loan closing may still take several
days or weeks as it does now.
Third, borrowers with a score below 620 may find
themselves locked out of the best loan rates and terms
offered. Mortgage professionals may divert these
borrowers to alternate funding sources other than FNMA
and FHLMC. Borrowers may find the loan terms and
conditions less attractive than the "A" loans, and it
may take some time before a suitable funding source is
located.
As
more companies utilize credit scoring, the loan approval
and closing time will be compressed for most consumers.
In the future, a high FICO score may be your ticket to a
speedy and competitively priced mortgage loan.
Credit Reporting Agencies
Equifax
PO Box 105873
Atlanta, GA 30348
(800) 685-1111
National Consumer Assistance Center
PO Box 2002
Allen, TX 75013
Consumer Credit Questions
888 EXPERIAN (888 397 3742)
Trans-Union
PO Box 390
Springfield, PA 19064
(800) 916-8800
(800) 851-2674
How to Correct Errors
You have the right, under the Fair Credit
Reporting Act, to dispute the completeness and accuracy
of information in your credit file. When a credit
reporting agency receives a dispute, it must
reinvestigate and record the current status of the
disputed items within a "reasonable period of time,"
unless it believes the dispute is "frivolous or
irrelevant." If the credit reporting agency cannot
verify a disputed item, it must delete it. If your
report contains erroneous information, the credit
reporting agency must correct it. If an item is
incomplete, the credit reporting agency must complete
it.
For
example, if your file showed that you were late in
making payments on accounts, but failed to show that you
were no longer delinquent, the credit reporting agency
must show that your payments are now current. Or if your
file showed an account that belongs only to another
person, the credit reporting agency would have to delete
it. Also, at your request, the credit reporting agency
must send a notice of correction to any report recipient
who has checked your file in the past six months.
For
those items in your credit profile which you feel
deserve further explanation (such as an account that was
paid late due to the loss of job, military call-up, or
unexpected medical bills), you may send a brief
statement to the appropriate credit reporting agency.
The information will be placed on your credit profile
and will be disclosed each time your credit profile is
accessed.
Credit Profile
A Credit Profile refers to a consumer
credit file, which is made up of various consumer credit
reporting agencies. It is a picture of how you (as an
individual) paid back the companies you have borrowed
money from, or how you have met other financial
obligations.
There
are usually five categories of information on a credit
profile:
1.
Identifying Information
2.
Employment Information
3.
Credit Information
4.
Public Record Information
5.
Inquiries
Credit Report Access
The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)
outlines specifically who can see your credit profile.
Businesses must have a "legitimate business need," and a
"permissible purpose," as stated in the federal law to
obtain your credit file. Otherwise, only you, and only
those who you give written permission, can access your
credit files. Your neighbors, friends, co-workers, and
even your family members cannot have access to your
credit profile unless you authorize it. Some examples of
those who can access your credit files are:
-
Credit
grantors
-
Collection agencies
-
Insurance companies
-
Employers
Any
company that receives a copy of your credit profile will
be listed under the "Inquiry" section of your report.
The
Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) is the federal law
regulating credit reporting companies like Equifax,
Experian, and Trans Union. It has been in effect since
1971. A revised FCRA became effective October 1, 1997.
This law protects consumers' rights, such as the right
to review and contest information in their credit
profiles. It also specifically defines who can access
the information in a credit profile, and how you are
notified of this activity.
Credit Questions & Answers
Why do we need credit reporting?
Credit reporting is needed because it
provides the information that helps consumers make
purchases, secure loans, pay for college educations, and
manage their personal finances. Credit reporting makes
it possible for stores to accept your checks, banks to
offer credit and debit cards, businesses to market
products, and corporations to better manage their
operations to benefit the world's economy.
What is a credit inquiry?
An "inquiry" is a listing of the name of
a credit grantor, or authorized user who has accessed
your credit file. Each inquiry is posted to the credit
file so you know who has obtained a copy of it. Credit
grantors post an inquiry before offering you a
pre-approval credit card application. These are listed
as "promotional" inquiries on your credit file because
only your name and address were accessed, not your
credit history information. They are NOT sent to credit
grantors or businesses for reasons of credit reporting.
They are listed for your informational purposes only.
What is the Fair Credit Reporting Act?
The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) is
the federal law regulating credit reporting companies
like Equifax, Esperian, and Trans Union. It has been in
effect since 1971. A revised FCRA became effective
October 1, 1997. This law protects consumers' rights,
such as the right to review and contest information in
their credit profiles. It also specifically defines who
can access the information in a credit profile, and how
you are notified of this activity. You may obtain a copy
the FCRA from the Federal Trade Commission.
How does divorce affect consumer credit?
A divorce decree does not supersede the
original contract with the creditor, and does not
release you from legal responsibility on any accounts.
You must contact each creditor individually and seek
their legal binding release of your obligation. Only
after that release can your credit history be updated
accordingly.
Should I use one of those companies that
promise to help correct my credit?
It's your choice. However, beware of
companies that promise to remove accurate information
from your credit file. Accurate information cannot be
removed from a credit file. There is nothing they can do
for you that you cannot do for yourself by contacting
the credit reporting agencies directly. Only time will
heal a delinquent credit history.
What if an item on my credit profile is
correct, but I disagree with it being reported?
For those items in your credit profile
which you feel deserve further explanation (such as an
account that was paid late due to the loss of job,
military call-up, or unexpected medical bills), you may
send a brief statement to the appropriate credit
reporting agency. The information will be placed on your
credit profile and will be disclosed each time your
credit profile is accessed.
FICO Scores
FICO® scores were developed by Fair Isaac & Company,
Inc. for each of the credit repositories. The scores
are: (Equifax) Beacon®, (Experian formerly TRW) Experian/FICO
and (TransUnion) Empirica®. They are simply repository
scores meaning they only consider the information
contained in a person's credit file; they do not
consider a persons income, savings or amount of a down
payment for a mortgage.
The
scores were designed to assess risk. They are useful in
directing applications to specific loan programs and to
set levels of underwriting, i.e. streamline, traditional
or second review. The scores are objective, consistent,
accurate and fast.
Many
people in the mortgage business are skeptical about the
accuracy of FICO scores. Scoring has only been an
integral part of the mortgage process in the past few
years; however, the scores have been in use since the
1950's by retail merchants, credit card companies,
insurance companies and banks for consumer lending. The
data from large scoring projects emphasizes the
accuracy, the predictive quality of the scores. Large
portfolios have been scored for mortgage servicing and
investment groups, and again, they demonstrate that FICO
scores work.
The
scores were developed from each repository's database
using actual loan performance. A sample of over 750,000
consumers per repository was used. The repositories have
each made great strides to increase the accuracy of
their respective database through computer technology
and internal monitoring. There is a new standard
reporting format for credit grantors to use when sending
electronic information to the repositories; this is the
critical first step to providing accurate data.
The
scores use a multiple scorecard design. Each repository
uses 10 individual scorecards, and the models at each
repository are the same. This increases accuracy and
optimizes the predictive variables for each
subpopulation. (For example, a borrower with two 30-day
late payments will be scored against a population with
some minor delinquencies.) This feature may cause a
borrower with delinquencies to score in the same range
as a borrower without delinquencies. Scorecards are
reviewed and updated every twenty-four months.
The
actual scoring process is proprietary, and the
algorithms are copyrighted. We can share the predictive
variables, the portion of the credit file considered and
the weight as provided by Fair Isaac. They are:
-
Previous credit performance (35%)
-
Trade
line information specific to payment history
-
Current level of indebtedness (30%)
-
Current balance compared to the high credit
-
Time
credit has been in use (15%)
-
Opening date
-
Types
of credit available (15%)
-
Installment loans, revolving accounts, debit accounts
-
Pursuit of new credit (less than 5%)
Inquiries
FICO has changed the way it factors
credit checks, inquiries. These changes should minimize
the "negative" effects that aggressive rate shopping or
the normal mortgage process can have on a mortgage
applicant. In the new Beacon version, the deduping
process has been expanded beyond seven days. One
variable counts the number of days within 365 days of
scoring. If there has not been an inquiry, the deduping
mechanism is not activated. If there is a consumer
originated inquiry within the past 365 days from
mortgage or auto related industries, these inquiries are
ignored for the first 30 calendar days from scoring;
then, multiple inquiries within the next 14 days are
counted as one. Each inquiry will still appear on the
credit report.
Scores should not change significantly because the
variable in the model using inquiries contributes less
than 5% of the predictive power of the model. According
to Equifax statisticians, an average of 5% of the credit
reports in the Equifax consumer credit reporting
database (over 200 million consumer files) will see a
change in score due to this. Fewer than 5% of those will
see a change significant enough to effect a loan
decision.
In
order to get a score a borrower must have the following
conditions in his/her file:
-
No
"Deceased" indicator on the credit file
-
At
least one undisputed trade line that has been updated
in the last six months
-
One
trade line open at least six months
Scores range from 350 (high risk) to 850 (low risk). A
scorecard of 660 will be 660 on Beacon 96, Empirica and
Experian/FICO if the data on each file is the same.
However, each repository is likely to contain different
data.
Every
score is accompanied by a maximum of four reason codes.
Reason codes identify the most significant reason that a
consumer did not score higher. They are not red flags.
Consumers with scores in the 800 range get reason codes
just as consumers with scores in the 500 range. The
reason codes may be used in describing to the consumer
the reason for adverse action. Scores are not part of
the credit file and are not covered by the Fair Credit
Reporting Act. Scores, if disclosed to the consumer,
must be related to the credit file - using the reason
codes - since the score has no meaning in itself; the
meaning or risk level is assigned by the lender and the
investor.
When applicants have erroneous
information reported, document the inaccuracies. The
easiest way to do that is to have your credit-reporting
agency upgrade the merged in-file to an edited mid-range
report or to a Residential Mortgage Credit Report. With
the upgraded report, you can ignore the score! The file
will have to be handled in a traditional manner for
underwriting and investment purposes. The developed
report will provide the paper trail that investors want.
|